传习录

337

337· 黃以方錄

先生起行征思田,德洪与汝中追送严滩[1]。汝中举佛家「实相」、「幻相」之说。

先生曰:「有心俱是实,无心俱是幻。无心俱是实,有心俱是幻。」

汝中曰:「『有心俱是实,无心俱是幻』,是本体上说工夫。『无心俱是实,有心俱是幻』,是工夫上说本体。」

先生然其言。

洪于是时尚未了达[2]。数年用功,始信本体、工夫合一。但先生是时因问偶谈;若吾儒指点人处,不必借此立言耳。

先生启程征思恩田州,德洪与汝中追送到严滩。汝中举佛家「实相」「幻相」之说。

先生说:「有心俱是实,无心俱是幻;无心俱是实,有心俱是幻。」

汝中说:「『有心俱是实,无心俱是幻』,是从本体上说功夫;『无心俱是实,有心俱是幻』,是从功夫上说本体。」

先生肯定了他的话。

我当时尚未了达。数年用功,才信本体与功夫合一。但先生当时是因问偶谈,我们儒家指点人处,不必借这话立言罢了。

As the Master set out for Si'en and Tianzhou, Dehong and Ruzhong followed him to Yantan. Ruzhong raised the Buddhists' real aspect and illusory aspect.

The Master said: 'With mind, all is real; without mind, all illusion. Without mind, all is real; with mind, all illusion.'

Ruzhong said: 'With mind real, without mind illusion — that is the work said upon the substance. Without mind real, with mind illusion — the substance said upon the work.'

The Master allowed his words.

I had not then fully reached it; years of work brought me to trust the oneness of substance and work. But the Master spoke then by chance, out of the question; where we Confucians point the way for men, we need not borrow this for doctrine.

  1. 在今浙江桐庐县南。
  2. 俞本,「达」作「迨」,连下读。
第 337 条 · 黃以方錄 | 传习录